Ethics in Community Psychology
Table 6.a
Challenges to Commitment and Ethical Action in Professionals Working in a Child Guidance Clinic
|
Sources of Negative Processes |
Negative Processes |
Challenges to Commitment to Values |
Positive Processes |
Sources of Positive Processes |
|
Competing definitions of: Who is the client? What is good for the client? Who controls clinicians' jobs? |
Systemic entanglements among worker, unit, clinic, school, and family |
Working in interlocking Systems |
Effective collaboration among systems |
Dialogue regarding: Clear expectations Mutual respect Role clarification Pre-referral consultation |
|
No team building No support for showing weaknesses Job insecurity Poor physical conditions |
Climate of isolation and insecurity |
Meeting workers' needs |
Climate of safety and support |
Team building Peer support Support from supervisors Proper space |
|
Mind-fix vs system fix mentality Threat to the status quo |
Pressure to comply |
Dealing with pressure to acquiesce to status quo |
Ability to challenge system |
Support from colleagues and superiors Good relations with schools |
|
Need for labels for placements Need for labels to psychologize problems |
Pressure to label |
Dealing with pressure to label children and youth |
Ability to assess without stigmatizing |
Less emphasis on labels Understanding negative effects of labelling |
|
Belief in expert model Restrictive orientation Need for power and control |
Professional arrogance |
Facing the perils of professionalism |
Professional humility |
Inclusive orientation Collaborative approach |
|
Lack of sensitive to diversity Racial and patriarchal biases |
Discrimination |
Facing racial and gender discrimination |
Equality |
Awareness of discrimination Commitment to equality |
|
Giving-in to pressure to be in schools |
No time for proper service and reflection |
Finding time and space for reflection and accountability |
Time for proper service and reflection |
Commitment to unit meetings and peer consultation |
Adapted from Prilleltensky, Walsh-Bowers and Rossiter (1999)
© Macmillan Publishers Ltd - Houndmills, Basingstoke, Hampshire, RG21 6XS, England
Legal Notice | Privacy Policy | North American site | Contact us